IPS - Infection Prevention Services

Home › Knowledge Hub › Residents, Families & Community › Consent and Dignity in Precaution-Based Care

Residents, Families & Community

By Lyndon Forrest, Managing Director, Infection Prevention Services (IPS)  ·  Clinically reviewed by Bridgette Mackie, RN & Dianne Newey  ·  November 2026  ·  10 min read

Consent and Dignity in Precaution-Based Care

TL;DR —

Precautions protect residents, but they also touch freedom, contact, and privacy. Good practice uses the least restrictive measures to manage risk, for the shortest time, with the resident’s understanding and agreement wherever possible. When capacity is reduced, the decision moves to a substitute decision-maker, but it does not leave the resident’s hands entirely.

Consent

This guide is published by Infection Prevention Services (IPS, Bug Control), supporting aged-care facilities across Australia and New Zealand with infection prevention and control for over 30 years.

Key Takeaways

  • Isolation is effective at reducing the spread of infection, but prolonged isolation can cause physical and psychological harm and is particularly challenging for residents living with cognitive impairment (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).
  • Isolation should be used only when necessary and when the benefit outweighs the risk of harm, including psychological, emotional, and physical harm (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).
  • Dignity of risk means a resident has the right to make decisions about their own care and services, even where those decisions carry some element of risk (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).
  • Aged care providers are expected to balance infection prevention practice and quality of life, and accept a certain level of risk collectively with residents, families, and staff (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).
  • Infection Prevention Services (IPS) provides infection prevention and control policies, audit tools, and clinical support for aged-care facilities, see the IPS HUB at ipservices.care.

Consent in precaution-based care means the resident understands what is being asked of them, why, for how long, and what happens next, and agrees to it. The Aged Care IPC Guide directs aged care workers to inform the older person about a procedure and obtain consent before proceeding (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).

A precaution is not a single procedure, though. Transmission-based precautions, a period of room-based isolation during an outbreak, or a change to visiting arrangements can run for days or weeks and reach into meals, activities, and family contact. Consent for something that shapes a resident’s whole week is a conversation, not a signature at the start.

That conversation covers four things: what the precaution involves in practical terms, why it is being recommended, when it will be reviewed, and what the resident can still do normally. Residents who understand these four things are much better placed to agree, disagree, or ask for something different.

Precautions a resident does not understand or has not agreed to may be applied inconsistently, and inconsistent application is itself an infection risk.


When does a precaution become a restrictive practice?

The line between a clinical precaution and a restrictive practice is a regulatory question, not a clinical one. It turns on purpose. The Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission defines each category of restrictive practice by whether the primary purpose is to influence the person’s behaviour. Environmental restraint restricts free access to a person’s environment for that purpose. Seclusion is solitary confinement for that purpose.

The Commission has addressed isolation directly in one case. Where a person is required to isolate in order to comply with a state or territory public health directive, that is not seclusion, because the primary purpose is compliance with the health order.

Isolation a facility applies on its own clinical assessment, outside a public health directive, is not expressly covered. The safe practice is to document the purpose. An isolation decision recorded against an infection risk assessment, with a review date, evidences a clinical purpose. One with no recorded reasoning does not, whatever the intent behind it.

Confirm the current position against the Aged Care Act 2024 and the Aged Care Rules before relying on it, and seek your own advice where a specific case is close to the line.

The Aged Care IPC Guide says the decision varies. It notes that the restrictive nature of a decision “may vary between settings, people and parts of the same setting or facility”. The Guide requires a risk-based approach that weighs two things together: the risk of acquiring and spreading infection, and the risk of mental, physical, and emotional decline in the residents affected (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).

The practical consequence is that a facility cannot answer this question once and apply the answer everywhere. Two residents in the same corridor, with the same organism, can warrant different decisions.

Need help implementing this in your facility? The IPS Hub gives your IPC Lead instant access to ready-made policies, procedures, and audit tools — updated monthly.


How do you decide whether isolation is justified?

The Aged Care IPC Guide sets out a framework it calls risk-based isolation. Isolation is implemented only after a comprehensive risk assessment, and that assessment considers the resident’s psychological and physical health as well as the impact on others (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024, p. 93).

The Guide lists seven questions for the person responsible to work through before isolating a resident.

Question to answer before isolatingWhat it tests
Does the resident have symptoms of an infection?Whether there is a clinical trigger at all
Have they been diagnosed with an infection that requires isolation?Whether a confirmed diagnosis requires isolation, rather than a precaution applied by category
What are the benefits of isolation for this infection, for this resident, and for others?Benefits, stated specifically rather than assumed
What are the social, physical, and mental risks of isolating them from family, visitors, and staff?The human cost side of the same ledger
Can the resident be supported to isolate safely?Whether it is achievable in practice, not just on paper
How do we minimise the time spent in isolation?Duration, planned from the start
If they cannot isolate safely, how can we reduce transmission risk instead?The alternative, before isolation is treated as the only option

Source: Aged Care IPC Guide (ACSQHC, 2024).

Working through these seven questions in the care record has two functions. It produces a defensible decision, and it produces the explanation the resident and their family are owed.

Related: MRO Precautions in Aged Care, Explained Practically


What is dignity of risk, and how does it apply to precautions?

Dignity of risk means that older people have the right to make decisions about their care and services, even where those decisions involve some element of risk (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).

Applied to precautions, dignity of risk explains why a facility cannot choose the safest option every time. The Aged Care IPC Guide is explicit that aged care organisations must balance infection prevention practice and quality of life, and that residents, their carers, and the workforce should collectively accept a certain level of risk. Its own worked example is maintaining essential visitor access (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).

This is the point most often missed in practice. Accepting a level of risk is not a failure of infection prevention. It is a documented, deliberate position that the Guide asks providers to take, because the alternative, eliminating risk, is not achievable without damaging the quality of life the care exists to protect.

Aged care differs from acute care in exactly this respect. Care is delivered in the resident’s home, so minimising infection risk requires careful consideration of quality of life as part of the risk assessment itself (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).

Related: Risk Acceptance in Aged Care IPC: Balancing Safety and Quality of Life


What if a resident refuses a precaution?

A resident with capacity for the decision may decline a precaution, and that refusal is a legitimate exercise of dignity of risk rather than a problem to be managed away.

The response is not to escalate but to work through the issue. Explain the risk in plain terms, including the risk to other residents. Offer the least restrictive option that still manages the risk, which is often not the first option proposed. Ask what specifically the resident objects to, because the objection is frequently to one element rather than the whole measure: a closed door, a missed meal in the dining room, a cancelled visit. That element can sometimes be changed.

Record the discussion, the resident’s decision, the alternatives offered, and the review date. A documented refusal after a proper conversation is defensible. An undocumented one is not.

Where a resident’s refusal creates a heightened transmission risk for others, escalate to the infection prevention and control (IPC) Lead and the Care Manager.


Who decides when a resident’s capacity is reduced?

Capacity is decision-specific and can change over time. A resident may have capacity for one decision and not another, and may have capacity today and not next week.

Care staff are usually the first to notice a change. Their role is to observe and raise a concern, not to assess capacity. What they notice matters: how the resident explains a choice, whether they can hold the relevant information, and whether their reasoning is consistent over a conversation.

Formal capacity assessment is a clinical decision, made by the medical officer or an appropriately qualified clinician, and in some circumstances it is a legal one. A cognitive screening tool may inform that assessment, but a high or low score neither confirms nor excludes capacity for a particular decision.

Where capacity is reduced, the relevant guardianship arrangements involve a substitute decision-maker.

Two things hold regardless of jurisdiction and are worth building into practice. Reduced capacity for a decision does not remove the resident from the conversation; they are still informed, still consulted, and their preferences still carry weight. And the least restrictive principle applies with more force, not less, when someone cannot advocate for themselves.

The Aged Care IPC Guide notes that prolonged isolation is particularly challenging for residents living with cognitive impairment (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024), making proportionality a clinical concern in this group, not only an ethical one.


How do you apply the least restrictive option in practice?

The Aged Care IPC Guide directs services to use the least restrictive isolation method that reduces the transmission risk. It also sets out what to do when isolation is not possible or cannot be delivered safely. Apply a risk-based approach that focuses on reducing, rather than eliminating infection risk through person-centred strategies (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024).

The Guide identifies groups at higher risk of physical or psychological decline from isolation, and pairs each with practical strategies.

GroupPerson-centred strategies from the Guide
Residents with cognitive impairmentOne-on-one care or a partner in care, which reduces rather than eliminates transmission risk while supporting person-centred care and supported time outside in a safe manner
Residents who are socially activeCoping strategies developed with the resident and their family before and during isolation. Communication methods such as phone or video calls. Pre-emptive care plans naming partners in care.
Residents with hearing, visual, or dual sensory impairmentA risk assessment with the IPC Lead to determine how best to support communication and engagement

Source: Aged Care IPC Guide (ACSQHC, 2024), Table 18

Two features of this table are worth naming. The Guide accepts that one-on-one care reduces risk without eliminating it, which is risk acceptance stated plainly. And it asks for coping strategies to be developed before isolation is needed, which moves the work from the outbreak into the care planning that precedes it.

Related: Living With an MRO: Resident Rights and Dignity in Aged Care


What should be documented?

Documentation is what separates a proportionate precaution from a restriction nobody can justify six months later.

Six things belong in the record:

  1. The risk assessment, including the answers to the Guide’s seven questions.
  2. The precaution level chosen, and the less restrictive options considered first.
  3. The discussion with the resident and their response, including any refusal.
  4. Who holds decision-making authority where capacity is reduced.
  5. The review date.
  6. What changed at each review.

The review date matters more than any other field. Precautions that outlast their clinical indication are among the most common failures in this area, and a precaution with no review date has no mechanism to end.


How does this map to the Strengthened Aged Care Quality Standards?

Applying precautions with consent, proportionality, and documented review is part of an infection prevention and control system under the Strengthened Aged Care Quality Standards (effective 1 November 2025), assessed at Outcome 4.2.

Under the Aged Care Act 2024, the rights instrument is the Statement of Rights at section 23. Three rights bear directly on precaution-based care: the right to exercise choice and make decisions affecting the individual’s life (section 23(1)(a)), the right to be supported to make those decisions and to have them respected (section 23(1)(b)), and the right to take personal risks, including in pursuit of quality of life and social participation (section 23(1)(c)). That third right is the statutory expression of dignity of risk.

The Statement of Rights is not directly enforceable by an older person in a court or tribunal. It binds providers through their registration conditions and through the complaints pathway to the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission.

Assessors look for documented risk assessments, precautions matched to assessed risk rather than applied by category, evidence of review and step-down, and staff who can explain the reasoning.

New Zealand note. New Zealand aged residential care operates under Ngā Paerewa Health and Disability Services Standard (NZS 8134:2021, incorporating Amendment No. 1), a different document from the Australian Strengthened Aged Care Quality Standards.

AustraliaNew Zealand
Rights instrumentStatement of Rights, Aged Care Act 2024, section 23Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights, under the Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994
ConsentStatement of Rights, section 23(1)(a) and (b)Right 7 of the Code. Right 7(4) covers care where the consumer is not competent and no one is entitled to consent on their behalf
Dignity of riskSection 23(1)(c), the right to take personal risksNot a named statutory term. The equivalent sits in the Code’s rights to information, choice and respect
Sector standardStrengthened Aged Care Quality Standards (effective 1 November 2025), Outcome 4.2Ngā Paerewa Health and Disability Services Standard (NZS 8134:2021, incorporating Amendment No. 1)
Sector legislationAged Care Act 2024Health and Disability Services (Safety) Act 2001
Substitute decision-makerState and territory guardianship law, enduring power of attorney, enduring guardianshipProtection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988, enduring power of attorney for personal care and welfare, welfare guardian
Restrictive practicesDefined categories regulated under the Aged Care Act 2024 and the Aged Care RulesNo aged-care-specific restrictive practice regime of the same kind. Restraint is managed under Ngā Paerewa section 6 and the Code
Lead roleIPC LeadIP Lead

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a resident refuse to be isolated during an outbreak?

Yes, where the resident has capacity for that decision. Staff explain the risk, including the risk to other residents, offer the least restrictive option that still manages it, and document the discussion and the outcome. Where capacity for the decision is reduced, the resident is still informed and consulted and their preferences still carry weight, but the decision rests with the substitute decision-maker.

Is isolating a resident a restrictive practice?

Whether a specific measure counts as a restrictive practice depends on the measure, the resident, and the rules in force. It is a regulatory question rather than a clinical one, and facilities should confirm the current position rather than assume it.

How long can a precaution stay in place?

Only as long as the assessed risk supports it. The Aged Care IPC Guide asks services to minimise the time a resident spends in isolation and to reassess as clinical factors change (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024). Every precaution should have a review date, and a precaution without one has no way to end.

Does accepting some infection risk mean lowering our standards?

No. The Aged Care IPC Guide states that providers must balance infection prevention practice against quality of life. It adds that a certain level of risk should be accepted collectively by the organisation, residents, carers, and staff (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC). Documented, deliberate risk acceptance is the standard, not a departure from it.

What if a resident cannot be isolated safely?

The Guide is direct: use a risk-based approach that reduces rather than eliminates infection risk, using person-centred strategies matched to the resident (Aged Care IPC Guide, ACSQHC, 2024). Isolation that cannot be delivered safely is not the safer option.

Infection Prevention Services (IPS) supports aged-care providers across Australia and New Zealand with infection prevention and control policies, audit tools, and access to experienced IPC professionals who can review how your service assesses, documents and reviews its precautions. See the IPS HUB at ipservices.care.


Sources Consulted

  • Aged Care IPC Guide (ACSQHC, 2024), Version 1.1 with January and March 2025 amendments. Pages used: p. 8, risk acceptance, quality of life, person-centred care; p. 9, harm of prolonged isolation, risk-based isolation, the benefit-versus-harm test; p. 37, dignity of risk; p. 67, inform the older person and obtain consent; p. 93, restrictive decisions vary, risk-based isolation and its seven questions; p. 95, least restrictive isolation method, Table 18 person-centred strategies
  • Aged Care Act 2024, section 23 Statement of Rights and section 24.
  • Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission, guidance on restrictive practices.

Want precautions that stand up to review without costing residents their daily life? The IPS HUB gives aged-care providers across Australia and New Zealand continuously updated IPC and AMS policies, audit tools, and support from experienced IPC professionals. Visit ipservices.care.

© Infection Prevention Services (IPS) | ipservices.care

IPS - Infection Prevention Services

About the Author

Lyndon Forrest MCom | Managing Director, Infection Prevention Services (IPS, Bug Control). Over 30 years of experience supporting aged care providers across Australia and New Zealand.

Clinically reviewed by: Bridgette Mackie RN, Clinical Director, Infection Prevention Services (IPS), and Dianne Newey, Senior Clinical Consultant, Infection Prevention Services (IPS). Digitally edited by: Andrea Murray BDS, Digital Editor, Infection Prevention Services (IPS).

Ready to Strengthen Your Facility’s Infection Prevention?

The IPS Hub provides aged care facilities across Australia and New Zealand with continuously updated IPC policies, AMS tools, outbreak management resources, and direct support from experienced IPC professionals.